George Hibbert (1757-1837), London, stamp (Lugt 2849), lower center, in black. ?D. G. de Arozarena (died c. 1860), South America and Paris. Friedrich Schindler (died c. 1913), Lindau, Germany, stamp (Lugt 2351), verso, lower center, in purple. S. S. Rosenstamm (1860-c. 1919), New York, stamp (Lugt 2839), verso, lower center, in black, sale: American Art Association, New York, Jan. 27, 1920, lot 77. Cortland Field Bishop (1870-1935), New York and Lenox, MA, stamp (Lugt 2770b), verso, lower right, in purple, sale: American Art Association, New York, Nov. 19, 1935, lot 41. Unidentified collector, stamp (not in Lugt), verso, lower center, in black. purchased from (Paul McCarron, New York)