William Russell, London; [sale, Christie's, London, 10-12 Dec. 1884, lot 403] (1884 ); John Charles Robinson, London; John Postle Heseltine, London; [P. and D. Colnaghi, London]; Private Collection, France; Private Collection, New York; [Eugene Victor Thaw, New York] (1983 ); all according to Cleveland/Cambridge/Ottawa 1989, p. 47: William Russell, London (Lugt 2648, stamped twice, lower right, blindstamp); [his sale, Christie's, London, 10-12 Dec. 1884, lot 403]. John Charles Robinson, London (Lugt 1433, lower right, in brown ink). John Postle Heseltine, London (Lugt 1507, not stamped). [P. and D. Colnaghi, London]. Private Collection, France. Private Collection, New York. [Eugene Victor Thaw, New York]