Richard Houlditch, London; Edward King; William Esdaile, London; Jean-Pierre Norblin de la Gourdaine; Connantré; Ruble; de Witte; Bryas; [Gallerie Cailleux, Paris] (-1958 ); All according to bill of sale of 9 January 1959 from Galerie Cailleux, Paris (photocopy in departmental file): Richard Houlditch, London (Lugt 2214, not stamped). Edward King (not stamped, not in Lugt). William Esdaile, London (Lugt 2617, lower right, inscribed in brown ink). Jean-Pierre Norblin de la Gourdaine (not stamped, not in Lugt). Connantré (not stamped, not in Lugt). Ruble (not stamped, not in Lugt). de Witte (not stamped, not in Lugt). Bryas (not stamped, not in Lugt). [Galerie Cailleux, Paris]