Karl von der Heydt, Berlin, by 1898 and probably until 1919 [lent by him to the Berlin 1898 and Düsseldorf 1904; photograph annotated by Max J. Friedländer, R.K.D., The Hague, suggests that von der Heydt sold the picture in 1919]. Duveen, 1920.3 Kleinberger, Paris and New York, by 1927 [Friedländer 1936]; sold to the Art Institute, 1931.