Nanna Rasmussen Lothe (died 1957), Lake Forest, Illinois; sold Parke-Bernet, New York, April 18–19, 1958, lot 321, as French, 18th century, after Murillo to Clarke [see copy of catalogue annotated by Clarke and receipt in curatorial file]; Mr. and Mrs. John W. Clarke, Chicago; given to the Art Institute, 1975 [the attribution to Veronica Stern was made in 1975 by Anthony Clarke in a letter to Patrice Marandel in curatorial file].