Probably Quincy Adams Shaw (died 1908), Boston [according to Valentiner 1947; Valentiner knew the picture as early as 1931, since he wrote an expertise dated Detroit, April 25, 1931, on the back of a photo in the curatorial file]. A. and E. Silberman Galleries, New York, by 1946 [according to Valentiner 1947]; Chester D. Tripp, Chicago; given to the Art Institute, 1962.