Rev. Pleasant Hunter (c. 1855–1926; also Dr. Pleasant Hunter), Newark, NJ; sold, American Art Galleries, New York, Jan. 1913, to Kate Sturges Buckingham (1858–1937), Chicago [Kate served as executor of her sister Lucy Maud Buckingham's estate and continued expanding Lucy's collection following her death in 1920]; given to the Art Institute of Chicago, 1925.